Bohemi Blog

Custom Engagement Ring Options: A Guide to Creating a Meaningful, One-of-a-Kind Ring

Custom Engagement Ring Options: A Guide to Creating a Meaningful, One-of-a-Kind Ring
|by Emily Sloat

For couples who want something personal, non-traditional, and beautifully handcrafted.

Create a Custom Engagement Ring That Tells Your Story

When it comes to custom alternative engagement rings, finding where to get a custom engagement ring made that feels deeply personal and unique can be a daunting journey. At Bohemi, we specialize in crafting one-of-a-kind pieces, from salt & pepper diamond engagement ring designs to imaginative custom engagement rings with birthstones that speak to your particular love story.

Why Choose a Custom Alternative Engagement Ring?

Have you been looking and looking at pre-made engagement rings and can’t find the one that’s just right? Or maybe you’re looking for something wholly unlike anything you’ve seen? Maybe you don’t even know what the ring of your dreams looks like, but you know you haven’t come across it. Opting for a custom alternative engagement ring means embracing styles that might be non-traditional, but are deeply personal and beautifully handcrafted. Working directly with a skilled designer ensures your ring will be as distinctive as your relationship.

Explore our custom projects here.

Step-by-Step Custom Engagement Ring Design Process

Step 1 – Select Your Center Stone

From the moody allure of an oval salt and pepper diamond engagement ring to the striking individuality of a colored diamond, to the dreamy elegance of a ring made with stones from a sentimental heirloom piece, Bohemi offers endless possibilities. Prefer a pop of color? Consider custom engagement rings with birthstones or other unique engagement rings with gemstones or sapphires for a splash of personality. It doesn’t matter if you’re drawn to classic white diamond engagement rings or you’re looking for uncommon cuts and colors of non-diamond engagement ring options, we’ve got you covered.

Step 2 – Choose a Setting That Matches Your Style

The setting is what compliment’s your center stone—the focal point and where your ring’s personality truly shines. It’s all about finding the perfect balance between aesthetics, comfort, and practicality. Do you love the elegance of rounded prongs or the sleek, modern look of a half-bezel setting? Maybe you’re drawn to the unconventional charm of an East/West orientation or the timeless appeal of a North/South setting.

Can’t decide between a bezel and claw prong? We can blend elements to create something uniquely yours. If your hands are constantly at work—whether you’re an artist, an athlete, or simply someone who likes a little extra durability—we can design a low-profile ring that offers both style and resilience.

No matter your lifestyle or taste, we’ll craft a setting that complements your chosen stone’s natural beauty and feels like a seamless extension of yourself. Explore our Ceremony Collection for inspiration and discover what speaks to you. Check it out here.

Step 3 – Pick Your Preferred Metal

Our offerings include recycled platinum engagement rings or recycled gold engagement rings in 14k or 18k yellow, rose or white gold, ensuring your piece is both beautiful and responsibly crafted. Looking for custom ethical engagement rings? We source our metals responsibly to honor both artistry and sustainability. Not sure which metal best suits you? No worries, we’re here to talk through the options and help you decide.

Step 4 – Add Meaningful Details

The devil is in the details, and personalized touches really elevate the sentimentality of a ring. From hidden gemstones to meaningful engravings, we can add thoughtful touches that transform your ring into something truly next level and one-of-a-kind. Want a coordinating piece? We can create a nesting wedding band to perfectly complement your engagement ring. We can also make it a full wedding set with a men’s wedding band to match.

Learn more about our custom projects here.

Incorporating Heirloom Jewelry into a New Custom Design

Looking to breathe new life into a family heirloom? Do you have a sentimental piece of jewelry that’s the wrong size, broken or just not your style? We believe that jewelry was made to be worn and enjoyed. We specialize in heirloom jewelry redesign, from reimagining sentimental pieces to recycling gold engagement rings as a foundation for something entirely new. In redesigning heirloom jewelry we combine old-world charm with modern craftsmanship, resulting in a stunning heirloom jewelry makeover. Let's take something old and make it something new, remodeling and redesigning rings can create incredible transformations.

FAQs About Custom Engagement Rings

Where can I get a custom engagement ring made?

At Bohemi! Our custom design process is all about you. It’s collaborative, straightforward, personal, and—most importantly—fun! We’re here to guide you through every step, from initial inspiration to the final reveal. Whether you have a clear vision or just a hint of an idea, we’ll work together to transform your thoughts into a beautifully crafted piece that feels truly yours.

Our focus is on creating something timeless—an heirloom that will be loved and cherished for generations. We take pride in ensuring your vision comes to life with precision, artistry, and care. From selecting the perfect metal and gemstones to refining every detail of the design, the process is tailored to suit your style and story.

Ready to begin? Book a complimentary consultation to discuss your ideas, explore possibilities, and start creating something extraordinary. Contact us or book your consultation here.

How long does it take to design a ring?

Our typical timeline consists of Consultation Stone Selection Sketch Production. From the first consultation to having your ring in-hand takes an average of 2.5 to 3 months. The design process can take as little as a few weeks and production takes 4 to 6 weeks. We can work with tighter timelines, but always suggest you start the process sooner rather than later. This allows as much time as needed to work out all the design details. Every step is tailored to your needs.

What makes a custom engagement ring special?

Your story, your choices, your legacy. It’s more than a ring—it’s a reflection of you. Every detail is intentional, from the metal’s hue to the shape and color of the stone, each decision carries personal significance. Whether inspired by a cherished memory, a beloved place, or a unique aesthetic, a custom ring embodies your journey and values. It’s crafted to be one-of-a-kind, just like the connection it represents. With every facet carefully considered, the result is a piece that feels deeply personal and is meant to be treasured. Explore Custom Engagement Ring Projects by Bohemi

Take a peek at some of our creations:

Ready to Design Your Own Custom Engagement Ring?

Book a complimentary consultation to get started with Bohemi’s bespoke design process here!

×